🚚 Cargo Box Vs Cargo Bag : All You Need To Know ⚠️

Mostly people are fond of travelling and they mostly used to prefer the cars for this purpose. The most common problem faced by many of them is storage capacity for that they chose either cargo box vs cargo bag.

I am a huge fan of cargo boxes and bags. I think they’re great because they are super simple to use. They also look great and last forever.

cargo box vs cargo bag
Cargo Box Vs Cargo Bag

The choice between the cargo box or cargo bag is totally depend on the users which suits on their vehicle the most. Sometimes it becomes so difficult to decide whether to choose a roof cargo box or roof cargo bag.

Let’s understand Cargo Box and Cargo Bag’s more in deep

The better option will be based on individual choice and requirements. In this article we have gone through the positive as well as negative points of both the roof cargo boxes and the roof cargo bags.

Cargo Box

Most people don’t even know what a cargo box is for a car. But it’s a good thing they do know about it because it can really save them money. It’s the law in many states that all new vehicles must be equipped with at least a third-party or “aftermarket” cargo area. What’s important here is the fact these boxes are so useful and so very popular.

  • A cargo box for your car is a box that fits inside the trunk or under the floorboard of your car.
  • Some people use them to store stuff like suitcases, other stuff like tools, other stuff like bowling balls, and yes even golf clubs! Whatever.
  • Cargo boxes are perfect for holding things like cameras, cell phones, and all kinds of other gear you might need in a hurry

In short, A cargo box is a hard sided box that fits inside your trunk and provides extra storage space for your stuff.

Cargo Bag

There are many types of bags available in the market, each with a different feature, size, weight, and price. In order to choose the best one, you need to know about the different types of backpacks available in the market. If you are going to travel by a car and need a backpack for it, it is essential to choose a bag that will be comfortable, lightweight, durable, and most importantly, one that has enough space for your belongings.

  • The material used in the construction of a backpack is its most important feature, especially when it comes to the weight of the bag.
  • It’s a soft case that holds all your stuff and has a strap.

In short, The cargo bag is a type of protective luggage, and it’s a type of car accessory. 

Check Out Some Great Choices About Cargo Box Vs Cargo Bag

  • In this article of cargo box vs cargo bag, we go through the basic differences as well as advantages or disadvantages of both roof cargo box and roof cargo bags which will help you to decide which will be perfect for you and also makes your work easier.

Β The Roof Cargo Box

Cargo boxes can be either designed for heavy-duty, general-purpose use or designed for carrying delicate or high-value items. Cargo boxes are often made of plastic and metal, while soft-sided cargo bags are usually made from nylon, canvas, or other materials.

Cargo boxes can be easily modified into various configurations, such as a carry-on suitcase, or into a bike bag, duffel, laptop bag or even a briefcase. Cargo boxes can be purchased in many sizes, ranging from small, medium and large to extra large.

The two main types of cargo boxes are the hard-shell and soft-sided cargo box. Now, Hard-shell cargo boxes usually feature four straps for attaching to a vehicle’s frame and Hard-shell boxes typically have a top lid with zippers.

  • A roof cargo boxes are just the big, sturdy boxes hook to the surface of your automobile and supply safe, weather-proof storage for virtually any sort of equipment.
  • Possessing a freight box is similar to having an extra automobile trunk that keeps your gear safe and shielded from every type of weather, moisture.
  • Many of the cargo bags need roof racks. They also offer the best security system which helps in keeping your material safe and make the user tension free so that they can easily enjoy their trips and make it memorable.
  • There are many roof cargos boxes which can be simply installed and removed by the user in a very small time.
Cargo Box Vs Cargo Bag


βœ”οΈ Good for sporting adventure.

βœ”οΈ Great for mobile lifestyle.

βœ”οΈ The side panels of the cargo box are easy to access.

βœ”οΈ Easier to carry. 

βœ”οΈ The cargo box has a lot more space.

βœ”οΈ Highly Durable


❌ Carriers affect gas mileage.

❌ Sometimes hard to handle.

❌ A loose fit can make your boxes look unfinished.

The Roof Cargo Bag

The roof cargo bags are a really easy thing that may hold your bag, camping equipment, and a lot more effortlessly.  The main purpose of the roof cargo bags is to provide users with more space for their equipment.

  • Soft-sided cargo bags have open tops, are lightweight and generally more flexible.
  • Soft-sided cargo bags usually feature two straps for attaching to a vehicle’s frame.

These totes range quite a bit in size, quality, materials and much more. These roof cargo bags are very easy to install and remove. The most crucial quality of the roof cargo bags is a flexible character and also can be easily fold into a really compact block and keep it away at a very small area.


βœ”οΈ Versatile nature.

βœ”οΈ Keep the belongings safe.

βœ”οΈ Useful for long trips or travel plans.

βœ”οΈ Can be carried easily without much effort.

βœ”οΈ Commonly fits to all the car models.

βœ”οΈ Highly flexible to use.


❌ Easily become damage

❌ Provide limited space.

❌ Less life as compared to cargo boxes

❌ Mostly not waterproof.

Difference Between Cargo Box Vs Cargo Bag

This part of the article helps the user the most to decide which is the best for the user. This part is consisting of the advantages and disadvantages of both the roof cargo box vs cargo bag.

NumberPoint to Compare of
1Security Features
2Storage Provided
3Water Proofing
4Cost Required
5Space Available
Comparing Cargo box vs Cargo bag with this factors

1. Security

  • While choosing between cargo box vs cargo bag, Security is one of the main things about which person thinks first. The cargo boxes are more superior than the cargo bags in terms od security.
  • Cargo boxes are provided with the extra security facility which ensure to keep the material safe. The locking bodies of the cargo boxes are made from durable material.
  • Whereas, cargo bags are not provided with the such an extra security facility. The user can not feel so relaxed after keeping their material in the cargo bags. For example, a bag can be split open with knife if an undesirable element so desired. 
  • So, in terms of the security the cargo boxes are excellent than the roof cargo bags.

2. Storage

  • One of the most common problem faced the user is the storage of bores or bags when they are not in use. In cargo box vs cargo bag condition cargo bags are better than the cargo boxes.
  • The cargo bags can be easily folded up to fit into minimal size. The bags have the versatile nature which allows bags to fold in shape according to the space.
  • Whereas, the roof cargo boxes can not be fold. the user needs a proper extra space like garage to keep this roof cargo box when not in use otherwise if you keep it anywhere there are chances that it may damage. If a person decided to keep it on their vehicle then it will increase the height of the vehicle.

3. Water Proof Facility

  • Mostly people love monsoon season so they planned their trip during the monsoon time. But the problem faced by them is to keep their luggage safe from rain.
  • In such types of condition, the roof cargo boxes are proved to better than the roof cargo bags. Cargo boxes do not allow water to inside it and helps in keeping the material safe.
  • Whereas, all the roof cargo bags are not water proof. Some bags prove to be best in terms of water proof system but not all. So, In cargo box vs cargo bag, the cargo boxes are much better than the roof cargo bags in terms of water proof facility.

4. Cost

  • The cost is one of the main problem of the middle-class family. They used to plan a proper ssssbudget before buying something.
  • In the race of cargo box vs cargo bag, the cargo bags are much cheaper than the cargo boxes so one can easily save his money by investing it in buying the cargo bags then roof cargo boxes.
  • A middle-class family can easily make their trip memorable by investing some money to keep their luggage and became free from their tensions.

5. Space

  • The roof cargo boxes as well as the roof cargo bag both act as the extra trunk which helps in increasing the storage capacity.
  • The cargo boxes are better than the cargo bags as the cargo bags can only provide the space of 18 cubic feet where as the roof cargo boxes can easily provide the space of 22 cubic feet.
  • The roof cargo boxes are better suited for the bigger families carrying the huge luggage where as the roof cargo bags are better suited for the smaller families.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Which One Is Better? (Cargo box vs Cargo bag)

The better option will be based on individual choice and requirements. In this article we have gone through the positive as well as negative points of both the roof cargo boxes and the roof cargo bags.

Both are perfectly good at their levels but in many of the cases roof cargo boxes are better like in terms of security, space and many more. This information readily assists the person to choose whether the freight box or a freight tote will be better for you.

Writing down my personal experience! (Comparing Cargo box and Cargo bag point wise)

  • The cargo box has a lot more space and is generally more durable.
  • If you need a larger storage space, consider buying a cargo box instead of a cargo bag.
  • Make sure that it has a tight fit. A loose fit can make your boxes look unfinished.
  • The side panels of the cargo box are easy to access. The cargo bag has a difficult time keeping its contents tidy.
  • The cargo box is a better choice for short trips because it is easier to carry. The cargo bag is best for long trips.

2. How much can 20 cubic feet fit?

The 20-Cubic-Foot Cargo Bag – Holds A Lot!Β 

Well, wonder no more because I’m going to tell you. It’s called a “cubic foot cargo bag” and it is exactly what it sounds like; it is one cubic foot of space which can be used to carry stuff.Β 

3. Do the roof cargo box and the roof cargo bags make noise?

Unquestionably, this arrangement will make some kind of noise. But probably not as much noise as would be made by a similar sized cargo bag.

Normally cargo boxes makes more of noise where as cargo bags make less noise as compared to storage boxes.

4. Can you put a cargo box on a cargo basket?

A roof-top-box must be fitted to the roof, and a roof-rack-mounted-basket must be fitted to the vehicle. The cargo box should be designed and manufactured to fit the mounting points of the cargo basket.

Mounting cargo boxes onto roof racks is the most common method used by roof box owners. A cargo box should only be used on a cargo basket when all the cargo inside the cargo basket is secured with cargo straps and/or bungees. If the cargo inside the cargo basket is not secured, using a cargo box may make things worse instead of better.


The roof cargo box vs cargo bag both provides the extra space for the luggage. The roof cargo boxes have many features like best security system, extra space, large storage capacity etc. in the same way the roof cargo bags also have some features like versatile nature, security system, storage capacity and many more.

Cargo boxes are used to transport and store cargo. However, the term ‘cargo’ can also refer to other types of containers that contain goods. In this case, it is best to use the word ‘bag.’ This article can easily help in removing the dilemma of an individual and helps in choosing the better one as per user’s comfort and purpose.

Show all Most Helpful Highest Rating Lowest Rating Add your review
  1. You are a great writer thanks. This difference (Cargo Box vs Cargo Bag) you have mentioned is so clear and descriptive as I can see.
    Written in simple and understanding way…
    But can’t you give any specific roof box to buy for my brand new KIA?

  2. Just wish to say your article is as surprising. The clarity in your post is simply excellent and i can assume you are an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission allow me to grab your feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please continue the enjoyable work.

  3. Excellent rack-mounted cargo box. Materials are premium, the design is fuel-efficient and interior space is plentiful. I can *just* fit my two Sportube 2-pair hard ski cases inside, but skis and poles alone fit with ease. Installation is absurdly easy. Really a great cargo box?

Leave a reply

Best Roof Box Guide
Enable registration in settings - general